Home > Data Center News > Data center locations ranked by operating cost
Data Center News:
EMAIL THIS

Data center locations ranked by operating cost

By Matt Stansberry, Site editor
25 Jul 2006 | SearchDataCenter.com

IT infrastructure news
Digg This!    StumbleUpon Toolbar StumbleUpon    Bookmark with Delicious Del.icio.us    Add to Google

What are the three most important considerations when building a successful data center? Location, location, location.

To that end, Princeton, N.J., location consultants, The Boyd Company Inc., recently published its list of the top data center cities in the U.S. The study compares the cost of operating a data center in 35 U.S. cities -- including 25 of the nation's largest financial centers as well as 10 other locations -- ranked by estimated annual operating costs, scaled to a data center employing 75 workers and occupying 125,000 sq. ft. of new space.

The ten least expensive cities by estimated annual operating costs:
  1. Sioux Falls, S.D. $9,684,282
  2. Winston-Salem, N.C. $9,799,928
  3. San Antonio, Texas $10,314,249
  4. Birmingham, Ala. $10,340,534
  5. Ames, Iowa $10,378,916
  6. Charlotte, N.C. $10,440,123
  7. Indianapolis, Ind. $10,451,796
  8. Tulsa, Okla. $10,452,228
  9. Des Moines, Iowa $10,480,298
  10. Columbus, Ohio $10,499,091

Sioux Falls, S.D., was the cheapest city, with just under $10 million in estimated operating costs per year. New York City was the most expensive city at just over $14 million, followed by San Francisco; Oakland, Calif.; and Boston. In fact, the East and West Coasts didn't fare well in the study on the whole.

"The selection process favored the midcontinent," said John Boyd, president of the firm. "These centers by and large are being located at a remote site from the corporate headquarters. Companies are purchasing large parcels of land at attractive prices -- creating a buffer zone around the sites if possible."

But that doesn't mean you should simply plop your facility in the middle of nowhere. There are several other factors to consider when selecting a site for your data center.

Price of power

The first criteria that comes to mind for many data center site selection experts is the price of power and its reliability. According to AFCOM's 2005 survey of its members, data center power requirements are increasing an average of 8% per year. Power requirements of the top 10% of data centers are growing at over 20%. At those rates, companies are less likely to accept high energy prices if they can avoid it.

Secure location

More on data center site selection:

Bad location puts data center security at risk

The data center and corporate headquarters: Together or apart?

A second factor is insulation from natural and man-made disasters -- another criteria where the midcontinent excels according to Boyd. Companies are shying away from the Gulf region because of the hurricanes; California for mudslides, earthquakes and wildfires; and high-profile metro areas because of the terrorist threat potential.

But Ken Baudry, president of Atlanta-based consulting firm KJ Baudry Inc., warned that data centers located in the Midwest aren't disaster proof. "You can build a building to withstand a hurricane or an earthquake, but if you're in the direct path of a tornado, your building is gone."

Networking infrastructure

Networking infrastructure was at one time the biggest factor in data center site selection, but according to Boyd, that factor has become less of an issue as most cities have come up to speed. "It was a question 10 years ago, but now we can look at the smallest rural community -- the network infrastructure is there, or it can easily be extended," Boyd said.

Accessibility

Access is also an important criteria -- and based on that, Baudry would list Dallas and Austin, Texas, as well as Altanta and Raleigh-Durham, N.C., as his hottest data center cities. "It's a reasonable day trip to send an IT exec on a plane."

Beyond that, companies need to consider accessibility to key vendors as well. "We look at cities that have a precedent for data centers," Boyd said. "If there's a precedent, vendors have gravitated to the area."

Talent pool

IT managers will also consider the local talent pool when looking at a potential data center location -- and that means evaluating local college IT programs. According to Boyd, the biggest draw today is for colleges that support the National Security Agency's (NSA) Certification for Information Assurance. The NSA offers a list of schools with the certification program on its Web site.

"The NSA certified programs in colleges and universities give a city a definite edge," Boyd said. "Federal mandates -- Patriot Act, Sarbanes-Oxley -- are driving this."

Local incentives

Another factor in data center deal-making is incentives from local government and utility companies in the form of cheaper taxes and rates. According to Boyd, local tax break incentives were first used by states in the Southeast to bring industry to the area, but now almost every state supports some kind of break for new business. "Every politician runs on the platform of new jobs," Boyd said.

Baudry agreed that most of the areas landing data centers are providing some sort of tax incentive package, and the areas that seem to attract attention have active economic development groups -- but it's often something worked out after the location has already been determined.

Despite the importance of site selection factors, data center real estate expert Peter Sacco, president of Franklin Lakes, N.J.-based PTS Data Center Solutions Inc., said site selection for many data centers is limited to within 100 miles of headquarters.

" Very rarely does a client say 'I can go anywhere in the world,'" Sacco said. "We don't' see site selection as a tremendous driver" -- at least not for midsized companies.

Data centers that are nearby are easier to manage and the cost of managing a remote operation can outweigh the benefit, Sacco said.

Sacco cited customers that are building data centers in the New York City area. "They sure as hell wouldn't be built there [if it was based on site selection criteria]. But that's where they want to be."

Let us know what you think about the story; e-mail: Matt Stansberry, Site Editor

Tags: Data center design and constructionData center site selectionVIEW ALL TAGS

Digg This!    StumbleUpon Toolbar StumbleUpon    Bookmark with Delicious Del.icio.us    Add to Google



RELATED CONTENT
Data center design and construction
Hewlett-Packard pushes smaller containerized data center
Facebook bets on coal for new Oregon data center
Oracle energy czar brings data center containment into vogue
Hot-aisle/cold-aisle containment slideshow
eBay's hot/cold-aisle containment in the data center
Yahoo's data center cold aisle containment
eBay uses plastic sheeting for data center hot cold aisle containment
Liebert's data center cold aisle containment product
Hot aisle / cold aisle containment in pictures
APC's data center hot-aisle containment

Data center site selection
Prefabricated data centers offer modular expansion alternatives
Study ranks cheapest places to build a data center
Renovate or replace outdated data centers?
Data center physical consolidation shrinks two facilities to one in 24 hours
The data center and corporate headquarters: Together or apart?
Things to consider when planning a data center move to an older building
Bad location puts data center security at risk
Rules for designing the urban data center

RELATED GLOSSARY TERMS
Terms from Whatis.com − the technology online dictionary
Electric plugs for each country  (SearchDataCenter.com)
green data center  (SearchDataCenter.com)
grumble line  (SearchDataCenter.com)
Modular Datacenter  (SearchDataCenter.com)
TIA-942  (SearchDataCenter.com)
tin whiskers  (SearchDataCenter.com)
unified computing system (UCS)  (SearchDataCenter.com)
Uptime data center tier standards  (SearchDataCenter.com)
water cooling  (SearchDataCenter.com)
zinc whiskers  (SearchDataCenter.com)

RELATED RESOURCES
2020software.com, trial software downloads for accounting software, ERP software, CRM software and business software systems
Search Bitpipe.com for the latest white papers and business webcasts
Whatis.com, the online computer dictionary



Efficient Management for Data Centers
HomeNewsTopicsITKnowledge ExchangeTipsBlogsMultimediaWhite PapersEvents
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  For Advertisers  |  For Business Partners  |  Site Index  |  RSS
SEARCH 
TechTarget provides technology professionals with the information they need to perform their jobs - from developing strategy, to making cost-effective purchase decisions and managing their organizations' technology projects - with its network of technology-specific websites, events and online magazines.

TechTarget Corporate Web Site  |  Media Kits  |  Site Map




All Rights Reserved, Copyright 2005 - 2010, TechTarget | Read our Privacy Policy
  TechTarget - The IT Media ROI Experts