News Stay informed about the latest enterprise technology news and product updates.

For some, expanded hyper-converged server choices miss the mark

Growing server choices in hyper-converged appliances give enterprise IT pros all sorts of options, but many are more focused on the software.

To some, the choice of meat in their sandwich can make or break lunchtime. For others -- whether it is turkey,...

roast beef, ham or salami -- it's all the same.

It's a similar situation for many IT teams with the servers used for hyper-converged infrastructure (HCI) hardware these days -- except if you prefer Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE).

Leading hyper-converged vendors continue to certify their software on an increasingly wide variety of hardware platforms. The newest addition to the mix is Huawei Technologies' FusionServer, which last week became a new option for SimpliVity Corp., of Westborough, Mass., alongside hardware from Cisco, Dell and Lenovo.

But the bulk of enterprise IT shops are less interested in growing hardware compatibility than the software itself.

Part of hyper-converged appliances' appeal has been as turnkey, Lego-like blocks. Another big factor for enterprise IT buyers is, of course, price. Many also prioritize how HCI fits into their overall hardware standardization strategy -- they have standardized on one or two platforms, so they are less resistant to adoption if the HCI can run on their selected platform.

"To them, implementing software on hardware is no big deal," said Eric Slack, senior analyst at Evaluator Group Inc., an analyst firm in Boulder, Colo. "They are fine with buying software and putting it on any compatible hardware from a hardware list."

HCI software does little to change customers' underlying hardware strategy from major server makers, said Lief Morin, CEO at Key Information Systems Inc., a reseller in Agoura Hills, Calif., that works with healthcare, finance, manufacturing and retail companies.

"I still have to buy hardware, so the question is valid: What kind of hardware do I have to buy?" he said.

Ask and ye shall receive

Already, SimpliVity's sales with Huawei servers totaled $5 million in the third quarter of 2016 for more than 100 all-flash systems running ERP applications, Microsoft Exchange, Oracle databases, custom-made applications, virtual desktop infrastructure and DevOps workloads, said CEO Doron Kempel.

I still have to buy hardware, so the question is valid: What kind of hardware do I have to buy?
Lief MorinCEO at Key Information Systems

Nutanix, meanwhile, has added Open Compute Project (OCP) servers from Hyve Solutions Corp. to its list of certified servers. Customers that requested this include an enterprise and a service provider that have standardized on OCP-compliant servers, said Greg Smith, senior director of product and technical marketing at Nutanix.

Part of the expansion of HCI software partnerships is to evaluate the key strategic partnerships for each vendor and what technology to develop internally.

Nutanix, for example, has certified its software on Cisco Unified Computing System (UCS) servers based on customer demand, even though Cisco is no longer a partner.

At the same time, Nutanix must solidify its relationship with Lenovo and support other appropriate server platforms for customers before moving on to new partners, CEO Dheeraj Pandey said during the company's recent first-quarter earnings call.

"We should not be suffering from attention deficit disorder and simply signing contracts just to sign contracts," he said. "Right now, we have to get a lot of what we have in our hands right, including Cisco UCS."

SimpliVity, on the other hand, will not certify its software on a server without a partnership with that vendor because many value-added resellers and customers would balk at the risk, Kempel said.

Still missing: Support for HPE

Amid the greater choices for HCI, the largest server maker, HPE, is still left out -- the top two vendors in the HCI market, Nutanix and SimpliVity, aren't certified on HPE servers.

HPE has its own line of HCI, to which it just recently added capabilities associated with composable infrastructure.

Customers want HPE servers, but SimpliVity hasn't been a priority for HPE, and the company wants any validation to be a collaborative effort, Kempel said. SimpliVity is not losing business due to the lack of HPE support. One Global 50 financial services customer asked for HPE servers, but when it wasn't available, the company went with Cisco, he said.

When asked recently whether Nutanix software will be certified on HPE servers, Nutanix's Smith said only: "There's nothing to announce today."

Robert Gates covers data centers, data center strategies, server technologies, converged and hyper-converged infrastructure and open source operating systems for SearchDataCenter. Follow him on Twitter @RBGatesTT or email him at rgates@techtarget.com.

Next Steps

What can you expect from HCI software vendors next year?

Understand HCI for VDI

The differences between HCI and blade servers

PRO+

Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

Essential Guide

Break down the challenges, benefits of hyper-converged infrastructure

Join the conversation

8 comments

Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.

How important is server choice when making a hyper-converged infrastructure buying decision?
Cancel
There are two parameters that are important when choosing the right server. The first, of course, is the type, i.e., NVMe, SAS, SATA and the size of Flash storage that the server can support and the second, which is the performance of the networking, i.e., 10GbE isn't enough to support the NVMe speed, and 25G in the new 10G). Also, many of those systems are using Erasure Coding (EC), so it will be good to use NICs that have EC offload engines, so less CPU cycles will be wasted on running non-job related tasks
Cancel
I think for now it can be tiered since NVMe, SAS, SATA.. their costs are varying. Someone has to educate me with this claim from--200 Gbps Mellanox: https://www.mellanox.com/blog/2016/11/mellanox-launches-200gbs-hdr-infiniband-aoc-and-dac-linkx-cables/

Cancel

Yes, Mellanox has today up-to 200Gbs networking solutions. However, my note was about the fact that if you do want to support the full speed that NVMe provides, it will require 3 ports of 10GbE, so using 1 port of 25GbE is, of course, much more efficient.

Re. the 200GbE, there are couple of applications, specifically, In-Memory databases that needs it. Also, soon, using persistent memory will be able to leverage such a speed

Cancel
Yes I got it.

Btw, I could not recall at the back of my mind, among these solutions: iWARP, FC, infinitiband, nextgen, RoCE, which of these have problems after 10 Gb speed. I think it is related to Random/sequential....
Cancel
In the data center, specifically today that HCI is getting used, Ethernet (EN) is the only network that is needed and RoCE is RDMA over EN. 10GE isn't enough and the 25 in the new 10. RoCE isn't about bandwidth, but about lower latency and much higher CPU efficiency, since no need to run the heavy TCP/IP stack that takes, and least 3 cores (I would recommend to watch the TCP/IP vs RoCE video at
Cancel
Cancel
Whoever makes it agnostic , will be the winner.
Cancel

-ADS BY GOOGLE

SearchWindowsServer

SearchEnterpriseLinux

SearchServerVirtualization

SearchCloudComputing

Close