Is air circulation a problem with a rear door heat exchanger?

When using a rear door heat exchanger, air circulation should not be an issue if the room has been designed properly.

We use rear door heat exchanger cooling. We have the hoses for the doors and electrical trays mounted in the 24-inch...

raised-floor plenum. We use ladder trays above the racks for network connectivity. We have no CRAC units, only an air handler to maintain positive pressure and humidity.

What needs to be addressed regarding air flow inside the room and under the floor?

I have Thermal Guidelines for Data Processing Environmentsthird edition from ASHRAE, and it doesn't seem to deal with a room populated with only RDHX and no CRAC.

There are really two major considerations with rear door heat exchangers (RDHXs), which are among the most energy-efficient cooling approaches available. The first is maintaining clear above-floor paths for air recirculation. The second is providing external humidity control.

RDHX cooling should need no additional air flow. If the room is properly designed and the cooling capacities of the RDHX units match or exceed the heat loads generated by the computing equipment in each cabinet, then the air discharged from any cabinet through the RDHXs will be at room temperature. The computing equipment will then draw the input air it requires from the room environment.

The discharge air from the RDHXs needs to be unimpeded so the room is maintained at a stable temperature. Air also has to be free to recirculate back to the fronts of the cabinets to provide equipment intake air. This is the antithesis of conventional modern data center cooling design, so it can confuse those not fully familiar with RDHX systems. You can even revert to legacy cabinet arrangements if you are using entirely RDHX cooling, placing cabinets face to face and back to back, but this is not necessary.

Building codes require that a certain amount of outside air be brought into a room so that people are not breathing stale air. This air should be filtered and may even be preconditioned before being released into the room to minimize contaminants and stabilize its temperature and humidity before it mixes with the data center air. It does not matter whether this air is delivered from under-floor or overhead. Since the quantity is small and it is not needed for actual cooling, and if it goes through a raised-floor plenum, the space doesn't need to be as high or as clear of obstructions as is necessary for full under-floor cooling. Further, a well-designed data center should be essentially a "sealed room," so the "makeup air" will tend to create a positive pressure that will also act to avoid air-born contaminant infiltration whenever a door is opened.

I am going to assume that the air handler you are using is a conventional office unit running off the building's chilled water system and that you are not differentiating between the two types of precision cooling units -- computer room air conditioners (CRACs), which contain internal refrigeration compressors and computer room air handlers (CRAHs), which utilize chilled water from an external chiller plant. I would certainly prefer a precision air conditioner in a data center, but the distinction is not critical to answering your question about airflow. The RDHXs and server fans should provide all the actual airflow needed for the cabinets on which they are mounted. Nothing additional should be needed to assist it.

Remember, however, that RDHXs provide only sensible cooling. They do nothing for humidity control; the water running through them is usually maintained at aboutfour degrees Fahrenheit above the room's dew point to ensure there is no chance of getting condensation on the coils. So if the humidity in the room is higher than it should be, the RDHXs won't remove it. Neither will they add humidity if it is needed.

Humidity control with RDHX cooling is usually provided by some amount of base cooling using conventional CRACs or CRAHs. This also removes heat from equipment for which RDHX cooling is impractical, such as network switches. Alternatively, humidity control can be provided by standalone humidifiers and dehumidifiers. But remember that, per the ASHRAE Thermal Guidelines book, humidity control should be via dew-point sensing, not by relative humidity.

The ASHRAE Thermal Guidelines book doesn't address these issues directly because rear door coolers are just one of many ways to maintain the thermal envelope that the book sets forth. The ASHRAE Liquid Cooling Guidelines book provides more information regarding devices that circulate coolant through the cabinets. Likewise, the Thermal Guidelines book sets the humidity envelope, but neither it nor the Liquid Cooling book tells you how to achieve it. That is the responsibility of your design consultant.

About the author
Robert McFarlane is a principal in charge of data center design for the international consulting firm Shen Milsom and Wilke LLC. McFarlane has spent more than 35 years in communications consulting, has experience in every segment of the data center industry and was a pioneer in developing the field of building cable design. McFarlane also teaches the data center facilities course in the Marist College Institute for Data Center Professional program, is a data center power and cooling expert, is widely published, speaks at many industry seminars and is a corresponding member of ASHRAE TC9.9, which publishes a wide range of industry guidelines.

This was last published in March 2013

Dig Deeper on Data center design and facilities



Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

Have a question for an expert?

Please add a title for your question

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

You will be able to add details on the next page.

Join the conversation


Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.

How do you feel about RDHXs?
The issue with rear door HX is air flow through the door. For high kW cabinets the server fans may not have the static to push the air through the heat exchanger. When this occurs the heat build up in the back of the cabinet is substantial. Fan assistance is required to provide adequate airflow. The design specifications of the heat exchangers must be understood. Some are based on very high temperatures with cold cooling supply to provide the largest delta T across the coil to show the greatest cooling rating. Values that are unlikely to be met during actual operation.
When I studyied this I found the rear door heat exchangers provided less head to the server fans than the standard cabinet doors.  I do not perceive this to be an issue based on that information.
love them! Have installed ColdLogik in my previous IDC!
I have not enought experience but I have a lot of doubts ... :|
efficient and quiet.
They are OK up to about 10kW then you can start to get overheating servers at the bottom of the rack. Back pressure caused by the door can lead to fan speedup and overall inadequate airflow through the servers.
Robert provided a solid answer. In addition, for an active RDHx you can set up a "laminar" airflow where the cool exit air is pointed towards the inlet of the next rack. Check out OptiCool for more info.
Check out www.clouddynamicsinc.com for next generation eco data center cooling
Love 'em, and anyone still using conventional cooling is throwing real $$$ out the window.
Coolcentric - RDHx and RDHx-LD - Top notch efficiency tools that empower data center managers to minimize energy costs while maximizing expandability, consolidation options, growth and installation options.
Simple Passive RDHx Technology is the most affordable and easily retrofit solution to growing heat density issues.
Very good explanation by Robert... Both IBM and Dell studied the Coolcentric RDHx and concluded that the back pressure and additional fan speed induced by the Coolcentric RDHx were negligible. These studies and white papers can be found at www.coolcentric.com.
Does the RDHx add pressure drop which would, in effect, cause the server fans to speed up, consume more power, and negate any benefit of using the RDHx?

What Dell tested:
Qty 4 - Dell Blade Chassis Servers mounted in a 600mm wide enclosure
Based on total rack power consumption of 20kW the RDHx increases total power consumption by 150 watts or 0.75%

Qty 40 - Dell R610 1U Servers mounted in a 600mm wide enclosure
Based on total rack power consumption of 14kW the RDHx increases total power consumption by 40 watts or 0.3%

What IBM tested:
Qty 39 - IBM x3550 1U Servers mounted in a 600mm wide enclosure with each Server having qty 12 x 40mm fans providing 35cfm/each at 25oC Air On temp. Total 15.5kW

Adding a RDHx is still within ASHRAE and chip supplier tolerances and has negligible impact on total rack power or temp rise.
There are RDHx's out there that are too large and they are only made for high density, blade center applications. The fin spacing is too tight, and the rows are too deep, and back pressure is an issue. They fit a niche market. Liebert and Rittal come to mind.

Fortunately there are RDHx's that are designed around 85% of end users out there. Coolcentric comes to mind with their RDHx and RDHx-LD. These RDHx's are more concerned about airflow and cooling capacity.

All of us know that fans are a choking point for active RDHx's. Sometimes it is necessary, but once you want to maximize every U space inside of your cabinet then the fans have to go. Especially from an OPEX standpoint, there isn't any other option to discuss.

I am guessing that Dells fresh air servers will be a game changer, as the "cold" aisle temps can for a limited number of hours hit 113 degrees Fahrenheit with 105 being the norm.  The implications for the hvac systems and generators to run the hvac systems along with energy use for these systems would be huge.  We can leave a laptop out in a 150 degree car and still use it.  So much for the prima donna IT people, as the cat may allready be out of the bag.